Appleton Estate 21

Appleton Estate 21 Year Old Rum Review: A Premium Jamaican Experience

The Appleton Estate 21 Year Old Rum has long been on the radar of rum aficionados, yet it’s often overshadowed by other 21-year-old rums that offer similar age statements at a lower price point. While options like the El Dorado 21 and Juan Santos 21 deliver excellent value, the Appleton 21 deserves its own spotlight as one of the premium offerings from Jamaica’s esteemed Appleton Estate.

Despite its somewhat modest packaging—featuring a tin can enclosure and a bottle design shared with the entry-level Appleton V/X—Appleton Estate 21 Year Rum holds a special place in the lineup of Appleton Estate’s premium rums. This category also includes the Master Blender’s Legacy, the 30 Year Old, and the ultra-rare 50 Year Old, with some enthusiasts arguing that the 12 Year Old should be considered as well.

Tasting Notes

• Nose: Upon pouring, this 43% ABV, dark copper-colored rum presents a deep, wine-like aroma with rich notes of dried fruits. While it doesn’t fully dive into the realm of wine-based spirits, there are faint vegetal and herbal undertones, noticeably lacking the signature citrus notes often associated with Appleton’s rums. As it settles, more complex aromas emerge, including burnt sugar (distinct from caramel) and delicate floral hints.
• Palate: On the palate, the Appleton 21 reveals a medium-bodied dryness, accompanied by a slight astringency that adds character without being off-putting. The smooth warmth of the rum evokes comparisons to a well-aged cognac, a trait also noted in rums like the El Dorado 15. As the rum opens up, subtle sweetness begins to surface, along with hints of lemon rind and nutty notes, possibly pecan or walnut. With further exploration, a smoky undertone develops, gently overpowering the sweetness, while a delicate thread of vanilla weaves through the flavor profile.
• Finish: The finish is long and satisfying, offering a layered experience of orange peel, cinnamon, and oak. This complex fade solidifies the Rum as a step above the Master Blender’s Legacy, providing a richer, more nuanced tasting journey.

While the Appleton Estate 21 Year Old Rum may not be the most budget-friendly option, its depth of flavor and refined complexity make it a worthy addition to any serious rum collection. For those willing to invest in a premium Jamaican rum, the Appleton 21 delivers a sophisticated sipping experience that stands out in a crowded market.